reader comments 74 with 60 posters participating Share this story
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Reddit The new Garmin Vivoactive 3 Music. Valentina Palladino Optical heart-rate monitor and charging nodes on the underside. Valentina Palladino Single side button for quick-start workouts and device settings. Valentina Palladino The Chroma display is still one of the best to use in direct sunlight (please excuse my sunburnt wrist). Valentina Palladino The new black, circular bezel blends in more seamlessly with the case than the metal bezel on the original Vivoactive 3. Valentina Palladino The new model has storage space for 500 songs. Valentina Palladino You can shuffle all titles, play specific playlists, or choose individual tracks to listen to. Valentina Palladino Heart-rate graphs show all-day pulse data. Valentina Palladino Device settings and battery level indicator. Valentina Palladino Garmin's Vivoactive 3 held one of the top spots in my list of last year's best wearables. With its sleek design, comprehensive fitness capabilities, GPS navigation, and NFC payments, the 3 more than held its own against the Apple Watch Series 3 and the Fitbit Ionic.
Today, Garmin announced a new version of the Vivoactive 3 with a feature that brings the device up to par with the newest versions of its competition: music storage.
The new $299 Vivoactive 3 Music is a smartwatch with all of the features included on the original Vivoactive 3 plus space for about 500 songs. It also has Garmin's new advanced sleep-monitoring technology, which uses heart-rate variability (among other pieces of data) to more accurately determine sleep stages throughout the night. I wore the Vivoactive 3 Music for a few days ahead of its debut to get a feel for how much of an impact these small, yet important, updates have on an already stellar device.
Garmin didn't mess with the Vivoactive 3's design too much, but immediately noticeable on the new device is the glass-like bezel surrounding the touchscreen. The original Vivoactive 3 had a metal circle and side-swipe features on the left side of its case—both of those are gone now, replaced by a seamless black case that appears to bleed off its circumference. The device is incredibly light, and its traditional watch design helps it blend into nearly any outfit. I appreciated the original Vivoactive 3's design because it was leaps and bounds better than the chunky Vivoactive HR. The small changes that make the Vivoactive 3 Music unique also represent another step forward in Garmin's hardware-design journey.
Further Reading Vivoactive 3 review: Garmin's often the underdog, often the better choice Music storage
Garmin introduced music storage on the $449 Forerunner 645 Music earlier this year, and that feature begins to trickle down into other devices with the Vivoactive 3 Music. Considering the original 3 had Garmin Pay capabilities, the only other advanced feature it was missing was music storage.
The Vivoactive 3 Music can hold about 500 songs (supporting .mp3 and .aac file types) downloaded from your PC using Garmin Express or from supported streaming services. Currently, the device supports iHeartRadio and Deezer, so Spotify, Pandora, and other subscribers are still out of luck.
Garmin vivoactive 3 Music Price: $299.99 at Garmin Ars Technica may earn a commission on this sale. Buy
However, the music experience is nearly identical to that of the Forerunner 645 Music, which is to say that it's quite solid. Connecting the device to your PC and opening Garmin Express allows you to do a number of things: download music, install software updates, manage Connect IQ apps, and change device and profile settings. The Music program automatically identifies the default music program on your PC (in my case, that's iTunes) and mirrors the folders you have in that program such as playlists, albums, songs, and more. Choose playlists, albums, an entire artist's archive, or individual songs to import onto the watch, and within minutes, the songs transfer to the device and are ready for playback.
After using the Apple Watch, the Fitbit Ionic and Versa, various Wear OS devices, and the Garmin Forerunner 645 Music, I know that the uncomfortable part of the music experience typically comes when downloading music to a device. The tools a company uses to get available music onto a wearable are less than ideal, but Garmin's is one of the least offensive and most democratic. Users are limited only to iTunes and Apple Music when using an Apple Watch, and Fitbit's music tool in Fitbit Connect is clunky and slow to transfer music to a connected wearable. Garmin made downloading as easy as checking and unchecking boxes to add music to a device, and individual tracks transfer in just a few seconds.
In my experience, playback quality depends on the quality of your headphones. In the short time I've had with the Vivoactive 3 Music, the smartwatch never caused any glitches or breaks in music playback, and my connected wireless headphones produced rich sound. From the on-screen music player, you can shuffle songs, skip tracks, and scroll through playlist and album track lists to select the song you want to listen to.
Further Reading Apple Watch Series 3 review: LTE comes with high monetary and mental costs Advanced sleep monitoring
In addition to music storage, the Vivoactive 3 Music will have Garmin's new, advanced sleep-monitoring technology. Most Garmin wearables track sleep, but the company improved on its methods by incorporating metrics like heart-rate variability to better estimate time in light, deep, and REM sleep. Currently, sleep graphs and charts in Garmin Connect already account for sleep stages and awake time, but the new feature should make this information more accurate than it was before.
Advanced sleep monitoring wasn't ready in time for me to test it out, but Garmin says it's coming soon. On paper, the updated feature takes a direct shot at Fitbit, which has focused more on accurate sleep tracking and analysis over the past year or so. I'm interested to see how much more in-depth Garmin's sleep graphs will be once it includes data captured with the new technology and if Garmin Connect will use the new data to push out more personalized sleep recommendations or advice. I did sleep with the Vivoactive 3 Music on every night that I was testing it, and its lightweight design and stretchy band made it a comfortable sleep companion. However, some may prefer thin-and-light bands to track sleep, like the Fitbit Alta HR or the Garmin Vivosmart 3.
Listing image by Valentina Palladino
Carry-over features
Aside from ditching side-swipe, Garmin didn't remove any features from the Vivoactive 3 when making the new Music version. It has the same Chroma display that's always-on and great to read even in direct sunlight. Garmin has a plethora of workout profiles that you can track, including run, treadmill, strength training, bike, swim, row, ski, yoga, and more, and you can choose your favorites to keep on the watch at all times.
Specs at a glance: Vivoactive 3 Music vs. the competition Garmin Vivoactive 3 Music Garmin Forerunner 645 Music Apple Watch Series 3 Fitbit Ionic Samsung Gear Sport Price $299 $449 $329 $299 $249 OS compatibility Android, iOS Android, iOS iOS Android, iOS Android, iOS Display 1.2-inch, 240 × 240 Chroma color touchscreen 1.2-inch, 240 × 240 Chroma color display 1.65-inch, 390 × 312 OLED touchscreen (42mm model) 1.4-inch, 348 × 250 touchscreen 1.2-inch, 360 x 360, Super AMOLED touchscreen Bands 20mm, interchangeable 20mm, interchangeable Proprietary, interchangeable Proprietary, interchangeable 20mm, interchangeable Heart-rate monitor/GPS Yes/yes Yes/yes Yes/yes Yes/yes Yes/yes Water resistance Up to 50 meters Up to 50 meters Up to 50 meters Up to 50 meters Up to 50 meters Battery life Seven days (smartwatch mode), five hours (GPS and music) Seven days (smartwatch mode), five hours (GPS and music) Up to two days Five days (smartwatch mode), 10 hours (GPS mode) Up to three days Music storage Yes, up to 500 songs Yes, up to 500 songs Yes, up to 16GB (LTE models) Yes, up to 300 songs Yes, 4GB internal storage Music sources iHeartRadio (All Access subscribers), Deezer users, personal files iHeartRadio (All Access subscribers), Deezer users, personal files Apple Music (paid subscribers), paid iTunes tracks Pandora (paid subscribers), Deezer users, personal files Spotify (Premium subscribers), personal files NFC payments Yes, Garmin Pay Yes, Garmin Pay Yes, Apple Pay Yes, Fitbit Pay Yes, Samsung Pay Extra features New advanced sleep tracking, compatible with ANT+ devices Training load, training effect, anaerobic training effect, compatible with ANT+ devices W2 chip, GymKit, optional LTE Fitbit Coach (limited free workouts, others paid), Fitbit Studio (easier app/watch face development) Rotating bezel, Spotify Gear app for saving offline playlists Further Reading Fitbit Ionic review: Meet the $300 fitness-focused smartwatch
Making your own workout profile is also easy on the device or within the Garmin Connect mobile app, which should also get recognition for its improvement over the past year or so. The heart rate monitor and onboard GPS are both accurate, the device receives all smartphone alerts to keep you in the know, and Garmin Pay lets you pay for coffee on the way home from a run without your wallet.
The kicker, though, is its battery life: seven days in smartwatch mode, or five hours with GPS and music use. Music lowered the former battery-life estimation (the Vivoactive 3 could last 13 hours in GPS mode), but that was expected considering the amount of power needed to play music through a bluetooth device and track exercise using GPS at the same time. After wearing the device in smartwatch mode day and night for six days, the battery was down to about 30 percent.
Rep counting helped the Vivoactive 3 stand out among its Apple and Fitbit competitors, and it does the same for the Vivoactive 3 Music. Each time I use a Garmin device with rep counting, I find the experience slightly better than the last. It doesn't always capture every rep in a strength-training session (it often doesn't think you completed any during leg exercises), but it accurately captures most reps completed when your arms are moving. Garmin's automatic exercise recognition feature in strength-training workouts also continues to get better—the Vivoactive 3 Music accurately identified half of my arm-circuit exercises in each strength-training session I completed. For the sets it doesn't understand, Garmin Connect makes it easy for you to identify the exercise completed, number of reps, and the amount of weight lifted.
While Garmin devices work with Android and iOS, keep in mind that Android users get a few extra perks thanks to the openness of the platform. Android users can send quick-replies to text messages directly from the watch, while iOS users are limited to reading and dismissing message alerts. Android users can also use smart notifications to pick and choose apps to receive alerts from on the watch—for iOS users, it's all alerts, calls only, or calls and texts only.
The cherry atop the cake
Much like its predecessor, the Vivoactive 3 Music is a well-rounded, extremely capable fitness watch. It's a more advanced fitness device than the Apple Watch and the Fitbit Ionic, giving users the power to go as deep as they want into their own fitness training. Those just getting started can easily track daily walks and nothing more, while hardcore athletes can customize training plans, track many different types of workouts, and now bring music along with them for the ride as well. Garmin's device also outshines the competition with its seven-day battery life, rep-counting abilities, and workout customization tools, and the company should be given credit for making massive improvements to the Garmin Connect mobile app over the past year.
But the Apple Watch and Fitbit's devices deserve credit for the areas in which they excel. The Apple Watch makes a better smartwatch if you have an iPhone, allowing you to respond to messages and even make and receive calls if you have the LTE version of the Series 3 Watch. It's inherently a better communications device, with the tradeoff being the restriction to Apple's ecosystem. Fitbit's devices have a friendlier mobile app than Garmin's, and Fitbit's social features make exercise a communal activity. Garmin has social features as well, and some athletes may even prefer them, but Fitbit's challenges, activity status and photo sharing, groups and other social features will appeal to a wider variety of users with different fitness levels.
The Vivoactive 3's lack of music storage made it a no-go for many users, particularly those who want to listen to music but also be free of their smartphones while they exercise. Now with music storage, the Vivoactive 3 Music is truly the best competitor to the Apple Watch and the Fitbit Ionic that Garmin has ever made—and it's made even better by its $299 price tag. If you're not married to Apple's ecosystem and aren't enamored by Fitbit's friendly hardware and software aesthetic, the Vivoactive 3 Music is the smartwatch to get.